“Sometimes it is necessary to go a long distance out of your way in order to come back a short distance correctly.” - Edward Albee, The Zoo Story
My first trip to Pisgah was a revelation. I will save the details of that first Pisgah ride for another time but it was that first trip that started my desire to explore all of the Pisgah district and see just where the trails could take me. It started out being all about the mountain bike but after moving here two years ago and having ridden all of the trails that are open to bikes many times my desire to explore Pisgah grew into a passion for hiking. Getting the dog only compounded matters.
So, this last weekend as I looked over my map trying to decide which trails to ride I decided to go for a little road ride on Saturday and then a big hike on Sunday. The road ride was just a little 40 miler down the Greenville Watershed and back home. It was good and I managed to dodge the rain which was an added plus.
The hike was something I’d been looking at for awhile: The Middle Prong Wilderness. I’d wanted to do a big loop of Haywood Gap and Buckeye Gap and figured it was time. At six am on Sunday morning my alarm went off and I jumped out of bed and asked the dog if he wanted to go for a hike and we were off. By the time we hit the parkway it was so foggy visibility was switching back and forth between poor to treacherous and I wondered just what the woods had in store for us. We parked at Rough Butt Bald Overlook and headed to the Mountains to Sea trail:

From there we picked up the unsigned Haywood Gap Trail without a problem and quickly were into the wilderness:

Haywood Gap was easy enough to navigate though the trail was very rugged and there was no mistaking that we were in one of the most remotes corners of Pisgah. A place where few people go and where you really need to be on top of your game. There is something very special about wilderness and as we worked our way down the stream side trail I marveled at the relics from the logging days and wondered how long until the forest laid full claim to the artifacts and left nothing but flowers:

I knew Buckeye Gap Trail would be on the right and also knew from the little information on the trail that I had found that the map was likely wrong and its location would be slightly off from what the map showed. But I planned on hiking the entire length of Haywood Gap and then turning around and coming back up Haywood to Buckeye so I paid careful attention on the trip down and noted where Buckeye likely started. By the time I got to Little Beartrap Branch it was clear that the map was far from perfect but I felt good about where Buckeye started. Little Beartrap:

On the return trip up Haywood I stopped for lunch at the big crossing of the Middle Prong and let Duma swim a little:

Shortly after we made our way back to where I think Buckeye intersected Haywood and we started climbing our way up from the river bank. There were water bars and other signs of trail work and my compass roughly matched the map (which I knew was wrong) and I felt confident that we were on Buckeye Gap. We climbed very steeply for awhile and eventually crossed over Grassy Ridge Branch at which point I felt that the trail matched the map. We stopped for a quick snack at this spot and then things suddenly changed:

After eating a granola bar and some dog treats we headed back up the trail expecting a sharp right turn to come soon but the trail quickly died out. I pushed through the brush a little bit thinking that maybe it was just hard to spot but couldn’t find anything. Then without warning the weather changed and a heavy fog set in. Visibility plummeted and it was hard to see Duma on the end of the leash much less try and find the trail. We double back to the spot where we had stopped for the snack and tried again but yet again what I thought was the trail soon died out. I used my compass but the bearings I was getting weren’t making sense. We should have been on a finger and headed East but it appeared that we were on a ridge and headed South which was all wrong.
Then the fog turned to rain and with it came heavy winds and thunder and lightning. I think the bulk of the storm was actually below us in elevation but we were very much in a tempest. I tried to stay calm and rational and kept using my compass to try and find the trail by heading out on a given bearing for 15 minutes and then returning to the snack spot by taking a back bearing. Eventually I deduced that we had somehow missed a turn on Buckeye and had ended up somewhere on Fork Ridge. I found some flagging tape that was obviously marking something and decided we would follow it. The tape led to an old extraction road or rail grade and we went down it for 15 minutes before I came to my senses and realized it was going to dump us on highway 215. Not wanted to bushwhack for a 1500′ descent only to have to hitchhike back to the truck I decided to return to the snack spot and then retrace our path back to Haywood Gap Trail and take the known route out of the woods.
Once we gained the ridge again I couldn’t find the spot. I’d been following the bearing but somehow it was no longer there. I was cold and frustrated and maybe a little concerned and just when I thought we might just be lost I found the spot. So we quickly headed back the way we had come. After 15 minutes I realized it wasn’t the way we had come at all and quickly headed right back to our snack spot. By this time I was very cold and knew I needed to stay calm and get warm and then make a good decision.
I always carry what I consider to be full survival gear and I started breaking into it. I put on my warm shirt and ate some more food. Duma looked at me hungrily and I shook the entire contents of his treat pouch onto the forest floor. By this point we had been wandering the ridge for two hours without getting anywhere and I knew it was time to go. Once Duma finished his treats he pushed his way through a few bushes and showed me the way back down to Haywood Gap. Within minutes it was clear it was the right trail and I was relieved. Good dog!
We made fast work of the return trip but it sure felt like even the snails were passing us:

In the end we were out there for 8 full hours and hiked at least 16 known miles. There is no telling how many miles we did while temporarily misplaced up on that ridge but I’d imagine 18-20 total is a real possibility. It was the closest thing to epic that I have experienced in a long time. Make no mistake the Middle Prong is the real deal and I can’t wait to go back and redeem myself. Fork Mountain will be haunting me in my dreams until I do.
I was very sore all day today. That is the first time a hike has left me sore so I went for a nice little recovery road ride after work. Davis Mtn. > Hebron > Finley Cove.